Differences between revisions 72 and 73
Revision 72 as of 2009-03-11 16:44:47
Size: 6462
Editor: ?MathieuParent
Comment:
Revision 73 as of 2009-03-16 03:30:33
Size: 6539
Editor: anonymous
Comment: converted to 1.6 markup
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 3: Line 3:
|| [http://trac.calendarserver.org/projects/calendarserver Apple Calendar Server] || (./) [http://packages.debian.org/calendarserver calendarserver] || {OK} lenny ||
|| [http://www.bedework.org Bedework] || {X} || not packaged ||
|| [http://www.bongo-project.org BongoProject] (was: Hula)|| (./) [http://packages.debian.org/bongoproject bongoproject] || alpha software, in Debian experimental ||
|| [http://chandlerproject.org Chandler] || {X} || not packaged: [http://chandlerproject.org/Projects/DownloadChandlerDesktop upstream debs] ||
|| [http://www.citadel.org/ Citadel] || (./) [http://packages.debian.org/citadel citadel] || {OK} lenny ||
|| [http://rscds.sourceforge.net DAViCal] || (./) [http://packages.debian.org/davical davical] || {OK} sid ||
|| [http://www.egroupware.org/ eGroupWare] || (./) [http://packages.debian.org/egroupware egroupware] || upstream development direction unclear ||
|| [http://www.horde.org/ Horde] || (./) [http://packages.debian.org/horde horde] || ||
|| [http://www.kolab.org/ Kolab] || (./) [http://packages.debian.org/kolab kolab] || {OK} etch, {X} lenny ( {OK} with APT-Pinning from testing), {OK} testing + unstable (see [:Kolab:wiki:Kolab]) ||
|| [http://sourceforge.net/projects/modcaldav/ mod_caldav] || {X} || not packaged, single developer and requires patches to apache source ||
|| [http://www.opengroupware.org/ OpenGroupware.org] || {X} || [http://alioth.debian.org/projects/pkg-ogo/ Alioth pkg-ogo] -- It's GPL; why is no one packaging? Previous packages [http://bugs.debian.org/285949 removed] (RoM). [http://www.opengroupware.org/en/install/debian/index.html Upstream packages] available. Nobody is working on Debian packages. Upstream development slow/unclear. Needs special fork of gnustep-make to build ||
|| [http://sogo.opengroupware.org/ Scalable OpenGroupware.org] || {X} || (fork of !OpenGroupware.org) not packaged; Patched to build with official gnustep-make as available in sid (compare OpenGroupware); providing a good default-configuration/debconf-support will be a bit difficult; upstream software has RC status, but has promising functionality (see below) ||
|| [http://www.open-xchange.com/ Open-Xchange] || {X} || packaging being prepared, see ["Open-Xchange"]; lots of dependencies need to be prepared ||
|| [http://www.phpgroupware.org/ phpGroupWare] || (./) [http://packages.debian.org/phpgroupware phpgroupware] || ||
|| [http://www.zarafa.com/ Zarafa] || {X} || not packaged, AGPL3 license is not considered [http://lists.debian.org/debian-legal/2008/08/msg00045.html DFSG free] ||
|| [[http://trac.calendarserver.org/projects/calendarserver|Apple Calendar Server]] || (./) [[http://packages.debian.org/calendarserver|calendarserver]] || {OK} lenny ||
|| [[http://www.bedework.org|Bedework]] || {X} || not packaged ||
|| [[http://www.bongo-project.org|BongoProject]] (was: Hula)|| (./) [[http://packages.debian.org/bongoproject|bongoproject]] || alpha software, in Debian experimental ||
|| [[http://chandlerproject.org|Chandler]] || {X} || not packaged: [[http://chandlerproject.org/Projects/DownloadChandlerDesktop|upstream debs]] ||
|| [[http://www.citadel.org/|Citadel]] || (./) [[http://packages.debian.org/citadel|citadel]] || {OK} lenny ||
|| [[http://rscds.sourceforge.net|DAViCal]] || (./) [[http://packages.debian.org/davical|davical]] || {OK} sid ||
|| [[http://www.egroupware.org/|eGroupWare]] || (./) [[http://packages.debian.org/egroupware|egroupware]] || upstream development direction unclear ||
|| [[http://www.horde.org/|Horde]] || (./) [[http://packages.debian.org/horde|horde]] || ||
|| [[http://www.kolab.org/|Kolab]] || (./) [[http://packages.debian.org/kolab|kolab]] || {OK} etch, {X} lenny ( {OK} with APT-Pinning from testing), {OK} testing + unstable (see [[Kolab|wiki:Kolab]]) ||
|| [[http://sourceforge.net/projects/modcaldav/|mod_caldav]] || {X} || not packaged, single developer and requires patches to apache source ||
|| [[http://www.opengroupware.org/|OpenGroupware.org]] || {X} || [[http://alioth.debian.org/projects/pkg-ogo/|Alioth pkg-ogo]] -- It's GPL; why is no one packaging? Previous packages [[http://bugs.debian.org/285949|removed]] (RoM). [[http://www.opengroupware.org/en/install/debian/index.html|Upstream packages]] available. Nobody is working on Debian packages. Upstream development slow/unclear. Needs special fork of gnustep-make to build ||
|| [[http://sogo.opengroupware.org/|Scalable OpenGroupware.org]] || {X} || (fork of !OpenGroupware.org) not packaged; Patched to build with official gnustep-make as available in sid (compare OpenGroupware); providing a good default-configuration/debconf-support will be a bit difficult; upstream software has RC status, but has promising functionality (see below) ||
|| [[http://www.open-xchange.com/|Open-Xchange]] || {X} || packaging being prepared, see [[Open-Xchange]]; lots of dependencies need to be prepared ||
|| [[http://www.phpgroupware.org/|phpGroupWare]] || (./) [[http://packages.debian.org/phpgroupware|phpgroupware]] || ||
|| [[http://www.zarafa.com/|Zarafa]] || {X} || not packaged, AGPL3 license is not considered [[http://lists.debian.org/debian-legal/2008/08/msg00045.html|DFSG free]] ||
Line 42: Line 42:
|| CalDAV protocol || (./) [https://wiki.mozilla.org/Calendar:QA_CalDAV_Support server chart] || N/A in KDE 3.5 or 4.0 || (./) || {X} || ||
|| GroupDAV protocol || It appears there has been some work 3 years ago, but it's discontinued. Alternatively there's a GPLv2 Add-on [http://www.inverse.ca/english/contributions/sogo_connector.html SOGo Connector] supporting GroupDAV contacts and freebusy info || (./) (calendars and addressbooks) || [http://svn.opengroupware.org/viewcvs/evolution-groupdav/?root=OGoProjects evolution-groupdav] plugin had no commits in 15 months. Fails to compile on sid. Old [http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=310834 ITP] was closed a year ago. || || ||
|| SyncML protocol || (./) [http://sync4jmozilla.sourceforge.net Funambol Add-on] || (./) (kitchensync) || There's a commandline tool [http://www.estamos.de/projects/SyncML/index.html SyncEvolution] || || ||
|| CalDAV protocol || (./) [[https://wiki.mozilla.org/Calendar:QA_CalDAV_Support|server chart]] || N/A in KDE 3.5 or 4.0 || (./) || {X} || ||
|| GroupDAV protocol || It appears there has been some work 3 years ago, but it's discontinued. Alternatively there's a GPLv2 Add-on [[http://www.inverse.ca/english/contributions/sogo_connector.html|SOGo Connector]] supporting GroupDAV contacts and freebusy info || (./) (calendars and addressbooks) || [[http://svn.opengroupware.org/viewcvs/evolution-groupdav/?root=OGoProjects|evolution-groupdav]] plugin had no commits in 15 months. Fails to compile on sid. Old [[http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=310834|ITP]] was closed a year ago. || || ||
|| SyncML protocol || (./) [[http://sync4jmozilla.sourceforge.net|Funambol Add-on]] || (./) (kitchensync) || There's a commandline tool [[http://www.estamos.de/projects/SyncML/index.html|SyncEvolution]] || || ||
Line 48: Line 48:
|| eGroupWare ([http://www.egroupware.org/sync see also here]) || (./) GroupDAV, LDAP, iCal || (./) GroupDAV, LDAP, iCal || limited support || (./) main UI || || || eGroupWare ([[http://www.egroupware.org/sync|see also here]]) || (./) GroupDAV, LDAP, iCal || (./) GroupDAV, LDAP, iCal || limited support || (./) main UI || ||
Line 51: Line 51:
|| SOGo || (./) calendar via CalDAV, or calendar and contacts via [http://www.inverse.ca/english/contributions/sogo_connector.html SOGo Connector] || (./) GroupDAV || (./) CalDAV (same as with DAViCal: Doesn't show entries made by other clients) || (./) main UI || ? || || SOGo || (./) calendar via CalDAV, or calendar and contacts via [[http://www.inverse.ca/english/contributions/sogo_connector.html|SOGo Connector]] || (./) GroupDAV || (./) CalDAV (same as with DAViCal: Doesn't show entries made by other clients) || (./) main UI || ? ||
Line 55: Line 55:
|| Apple Calendar Server || XML, SQLite, Apache file, Open Directory, [http://trac.calendarserver.org/projects/calendarserver/ticket/271 NSS] || GSSAPI, plain, digest || || Apple Calendar Server || XML, SQLite, Apache file, Open Directory, [[http://trac.calendarserver.org/projects/calendarserver/ticket/271|NSS]] || GSSAPI, plain, digest ||
Line 64: Line 64:
There were a groupware meeting [:GroupwareMeeting2008-04-25to27:wiki:GroupwareMeeting2008-04-25to27]
and we are organising a new one [:GroupwareMeeting2009-04-17to19:wiki:GroupwareMeeting2009-04-17to19]
There were a groupware meeting [[GroupwareMeeting2008-04-25to27|wiki:GroupwareMeeting2008-04-25to27]]
and we are organising a new one [[GroupwareMeeting2009-04-17to19|wiki:GroupwareMeeting2009-04-17to19]]

Groupware in Debian

Name

in Debian (packages.d.o link)

Status, current issues

Apple Calendar Server

(./) calendarserver

{OK} lenny

Bedework

{X}

not packaged

BongoProject (was: Hula)

(./) bongoproject

alpha software, in Debian experimental

Chandler

{X}

not packaged: upstream debs

Citadel

(./) citadel

{OK} lenny

DAViCal

(./) davical

{OK} sid

eGroupWare

(./) egroupware

upstream development direction unclear

Horde

(./) horde

Kolab

(./) kolab

{OK} etch, {X} lenny ( {OK} with APT-Pinning from testing), {OK} testing + unstable (see wiki:Kolab)

mod_caldav

{X}

not packaged, single developer and requires patches to apache source

OpenGroupware.org

{X}

Alioth pkg-ogo -- It's GPL; why is no one packaging? Previous packages removed (RoM). Upstream packages available. Nobody is working on Debian packages. Upstream development slow/unclear. Needs special fork of gnustep-make to build

Scalable OpenGroupware.org

{X}

(fork of OpenGroupware.org) not packaged; Patched to build with official gnustep-make as available in sid (compare ?OpenGroupware); providing a good default-configuration/debconf-support will be a bit difficult; upstream software has RC status, but has promising functionality (see below)

Open-Xchange

{X}

packaging being prepared, see Open-Xchange; lots of dependencies need to be prepared

phpGroupWare

(./) phpgroupware

Zarafa

{X}

not packaged, AGPL3 license is not considered DFSG free

Features

Roughly, we consider groupware to include:

  • email
  • addressbook
  • calendar
  • tasks
  • notes

and integration between these components.

Other functionality such as chat or ticket systems are not considered on this page.

Email

Addressbook

Calendar

Tasks

Notes

Apple Calendar Server

-

-

(./)

(./)

-

BongoProject

(./)

?

(./)

?

?

Citadel

(./)

(./)

(./)

(./)

(./)

eGroupWare

(./)

(./)

(./)

(./)

-

Horde

(./)

(./)

(./)

(./)

(./)

Kolab

(./)

(./)

(./)

(./)

(./)

phpGroupWare

(./)

(./)

(./)

(./)

-

SOGo

(./)

(./)

(./)

(./)

-

Compatibility

Ice*

Kontact

Evolution

Web Interface

Outlook

CalDAV protocol

(./) server chart

N/A in KDE 3.5 or 4.0

(./)

{X}

GroupDAV protocol

It appears there has been some work 3 years ago, but it's discontinued. Alternatively there's a GPLv2 Add-on SOGo Connector supporting GroupDAV contacts and freebusy info

(./) (calendars and addressbooks)

evolution-groupdav plugin had no commits in 15 months. Fails to compile on sid. Old ITP was closed a year ago.

SyncML protocol

(./) Funambol Add-on

(./) (kitchensync)

There's a commandline tool SyncEvolution

Apple Calendar Server

(./) CalDAV

{X}

(./) CalDAV

{X}

Citadel

See GroupDAV protocol. IMAP/POP/SMTP work.

(./) See GroupDAV protocol; IMAP/POP/SMTP work.

See GroupDAV protocol. IMAP/POP/SMTP work.

(./)

yes, proprietary

DAViCal

(./) CalDAV

No CalDAV support in Kontact, but it actually works to some degree using the "remote file" KDE resource.

See CalDAV protocol. But Evolution fails to show events created by other clients.

only for administration

eGroupWare (see also here)

(./) GroupDAV, LDAP, iCal

(./) GroupDAV, LDAP, iCal

limited support

(./) main UI

Horde

only addresses via LDAP

only addresses via LDAP, calendar via Kolab

only addresses via LDAP

(./) main UI

{X}

Kolab

with kolabsync (not packaged)

(./)

{X}

(./) via Horde

yes, proprietary

SOGo

(./) calendar via CalDAV, or calendar and contacts via SOGo Connector

(./) GroupDAV

(./) CalDAV (same as with DAViCal: Doesn't show entries made by other clients)

(./) main UI

?

Authentication and User Databases

Users stored in

Authentication options

Apple Calendar Server

XML, SQLite, Apache file, Open Directory, NSS

GSSAPI, plain, digest

Citadel

internal

internal, PAM

DAViCal

PostgreSQL

?

eGroupWare

LDAP, SQL

SQL, LDAP, Active Directory, IMAP, HTTP, NIS, PAM

Horde

?

?

Kolab

LDAP

SASL

SOGo

LDAP

LDAP

Meeting

There were a groupware meeting wiki:GroupwareMeeting2008-04-25to27 and we are organising a new one wiki:GroupwareMeeting2009-04-17to19