Differences between revisions 562 and 563
Revision 562 as of 2010-11-01 05:35:14
Size: 25109
Editor: ?Lee Winter
Comment: Reviewed 2010-10, found 11 spam
Revision 563 as of 2010-11-01 07:10:56
Size: 25120
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 31: Line 31:
|| [[http://lists.debian.org/debian-boot/2010/10/|2010/10]] || 1 || lee:11 || || [[http://lists.debian.org/debian-boot/2010/10/|2010/10]] || 2 || lee:11 bubulle:12 ||

This work was initiated in 2009 by Frans Pop and has been one of his numerous contributions to Debian. Thanks, Frans, for starting this as meticulously as you always did with your work in the project.

Cleaning spam from the debian-boot list

Now that the listmasters have created a working toolset to actually remove spam from the mailing list archives, it seems like a good idea to make a coordinated effort to clean spam from the list archives.

This page is intended to coordinate the reporting of spam in the archive for the debian-boot list.

What's needed is that a few people go through the list archive for every month and consistently report all spam that they see. That should get the messages listed for the next stage, the review by DDs of reported spam, and their eventual removal.

Please try to be as thorough as possible: try to report all spam, but also try not to report mails that are not spam. In general spam is fairly easy to recognize from the subject of the messages, so let's start there: just go through the thread index for a month, select suspicious messages, report them, and then either return to the index (using "back" two times) or go to the next message (using the "thread next" link). I've found that this works well if you look ahead a bit on the index page to check if there's a series of spam messages.

Spam needs to be reported by multiple people. But to avoid too many people doing the same months, please register in the table below which months you've checked. Let's start with the most recent years.

/!\ A message currently must have 5 nominations to pass to the review stage.

/!\ The batch job that makes nominated posts available for review and removes posts classified as spam runs only once a week (Sundays).

Old archive reviews have been moved at the end of this wiki page. There shouldn't be any need to review archives before January 1st 2010, now.

year/month

nr. of reviews

checked by (separate names/nicks/initials by a space)

2010/01

6

fjp lee:25 dww bubulle:23 fp sc

2010/02

7

fjp bubulle:26 fp lee:25 elmig sc dww:1

2010/03

6

lee:16 bubulle:16 elmig sc dww hwansing

2010/04

7

bubulle:3 lee:3 fjp:3 dww:3 fp:3 elmig:3 sc:3

2010/05

6

lee:18 sc:18 bubulle:20 dww:20? fjp hwansing

2010/06

5

bubulle:22 lee:23 hwansing dww:23 elmig

2010/07

5

bubulle:14 lee:13 hwansing dww:15 sc

2010/08

5

dww sc bubulle hwansing lee:8

2010/09

6

bubulle sc dww elmig hwansing lee:30

2010/10

2

lee:11 bubulle:12

Status according to Listarchive Review Statistic page:

date

nominations

posts

reviews

removed spam

classified as

nominated

considered

total

spam

ham

inappropriate

ham

inappropriate

2009/05/02

16117

4364

284

291

170

121

0

0

N/A

N/A

2009/05/03

18297

4657

659

591

344

242

5

16

N/A

N/A

2009/05/10

24378

5253

1361

1732

1223

497

12

233

123

0

2009/05/17

27557

5355

2010

3666

3125

526

15

676

143

0

2009/05/24

29647

5402

2584

7434

6830

587

17

1801

159

0

2009/05/31

31091

5438

3124

9697

9082

595

20

2381

159

0

2009/06/07

32082

5590

3332

10826

10209

595

22

2441

159

0

2009/06/14

32696

5954

3386

11298

10681

595

22

2491

159

0

2009/06/21

33084

6158

3419

11407

10790

595

22

2491

159

0

2009/06/28

33697

6672

3427

11540

10921

597

22

2554

160

0

2009/07/05

35062

7584

3496

12027

11407

598

22

3015

161

0

2009/07/12

36104

8212

3515

12280

11660

598

22

3129

161

0

2009/07/19

36266

8275

3523

12300

11680

598

22

3130

161

0

2009/07/26

36995

8380

3534

12335

11715

598

22

3130

161

0

2009/08/02

37828

8453

3607

12357

11737

598

22

3130

161

0

2009/08/09

38582

8498

3693

13197

12538

616

43

3403

169

0

2009/08/16

39038

8523

3720

13453

12771

617

65

3463

169

0

2009/08/23

39707

8556

3720

13534

12848

617

69

3488

169

0

2009/08/30

39873

8568

3720

13535

12849

617

69

3489

169

0

2009/09/06

40457

8589

3770

13535

12849

617

69

3489

169

0

2009/09/13

40482

8598

3778

13817

13120

626

71

3549

170

0

2009/09/20

40729

8608

3798

13848

13151

626

71

3557

170

0

2009/09/27

40816

8610

3800

13916

13218

626

72

3575

170

0

2009/10/04

40870

8619

3801

13926

13227

626

73

3577

170

0

2009/10/11

41186

8631

3827

13930

13231

626

73

3578

170

0

2009/10/18

41198

8636

3827

14034

13335

626

73

3604

170

0

2009/10/25

41201

8638

3827

14087

13368

635

84

3622

170

0

2009/11/01

41209

8644

3827

14087

13368

635

84

3622

170

0

2009/11/08

43909

8922

4275

14087

13368

635

84

3622

170

0

2009/11/15

44487

8980

4483

15573

14800

639

134

3986

171

1

2009/11/22

44525

8987

4492

16261

14485

639

137

4239

171

1

2009/11/29

44640

8990

4501

16317

15531

643

143

4252

173

1

2009/12/06

44665

8995

4510

16344

15558

643

143

4261

173

1

2009/12/13

44711

8998

4530

16371

15585

643

143

4270

173

1

2009/12/20

45910

9044

4771

16431

15645

643

143

4290

173

1

2009/12/27

46147

9057

4772

17152

16366

643

143

4529

173

1

2010/01/03

46201

9063

4784

17289

16413

649

227

4533

174

4

2010/01/10

46230

9064

4789

17425

16468

654

303

4545

176

4

2010/01/17

46249

9068

4790

17446

16489

654

303

4550

176

4

2010/01/24

47763

9096

5234

17502

16515

654

333

4552

176

5

2010/01/31

48058

9128

5253

18869

17879

654

336

4977

176

5

2010/02/07

48238

9141

5311

18942

17952

654

336

5012

176

5

2010/02/14

48266

9151

5311

19059

18069

654

336

5013

176

5

2010/02/21

48331

9177

5326

19059

18069

654

336

5013

176

5

2010/02/28

48364

9187

5333

19162

18166

654

342

5083

176

5

2010/03/07

48553

9200

5439

19244

18195

654

395

5089

176

6

2010/03/14

48623

9208

5445

19562

18511

654

397

5194

176

6

2010/03/21

48635

9214

5446

19574

18523

654

397

5194

176

6

2010/03/28

48649

9218

5450

19583

18532

654

397

5201

176

6

2010/04/04

48707

9225

5464

19604

18548

654

402

5205

176

6

2010/04/18

48801

9230

5480

19720

18662

654

404

5219

176

7

2010/04/25

48812

9238

5480

19737

18679

654

404

5219

176

7

2010/05/02

48823

9240

5480

19753

18695

654

404

5235

176

7

2010/05/09

48857

9249

5483

19753

18695

654

404

5235

176

7

2010/05/16

48872

9255

5483

19762

18704

654

404

5238

176

7

2010/05/23

48876

9258

5483

19762

18704

654

404

5238

176

7

2010/05/30

48903

9266

5485

19762

18704

654

404

5238

176

7

2010/06/06

49003

9268

5504

19766

18706

656

404

5238

176

7

2010/06/13

49067

9279

5504

19824

18763

657

404

5257

177

7

2010/06/20

49076

9283

5504

19824

18763

657

404

5257

177

7

2010/06/27

49110

9291

5508

19824

18763

657

404

5257

177

7

2010/07/11

49270

9299

5527

19891

18813

659

419

5262

177

7

2010/07/18

49278

9301

5527

19910

18832

659

419

5262

177

7

2010/07/25

49308

9304

5530

19929

18851

659

419

5262

177

7

2010/08/01

49330

9310

5535

19932

18854

659

419

5262

177

7

2010/08/08

49414

9314

5541

19937

18859

659

419

5262

177

7

2010/08/22

49479

9324

5551

19961

18883

659

419

5262

177

7

2010/08/29

49479

9324

5551

19961

18883

659

419

5262

177

7

2010/09/05

49593

9334

5559

20105

18963

661

481

5300

177

11

2010/09/12

49610

9338

5559

20170

18984

663

523

5306

177

12

2010/09/19

49623

9344

5559

20170

18984

663

523

5306

177

12

2010/09/26

49715

9372

5563

20170

18984

663

523

5306

177

12

2010/10/03

49750

9375

5576

20204

19010

663

531

5308

177

12

2010/10/10

49966

9379

5595

20234

19040

663

531

5312

177

12

2010/10/17

49984

9384

5595

20252

19058

663

531

5312

177

12

2010/10/24

50000

9388

5597

20253

19059

663

531

5312

177

12

2010/10/31

50004

9391

5597

20276

19082

663

531

5312

177

12

Old archives review

There shouldn't be any need to review these again. The following is kept just for reference.

year/month

nr. of reviews

checked by (separate names/nicks/initials by a space)

1998/11

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1998/12

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/01

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/02

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/03

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/04

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/05

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/06

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/07

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/08

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/09

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/10

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/11

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

1999/12

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2000/01

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2000/02

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2000/03

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2000/04

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2000/05

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2000/06

5

bubulle cate lee hwansing fjp

2000/07

5

bubulle cate lee hwansing fjp

2000/08

5

bubulle cate lee hwansing fjp

2000/09

5

bubulle cate lee hwansing fjp

2000/10

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2000/11

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2000/12

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2001/01

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2001/02

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2001/03

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp sc

2001/04

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp bertol

2001/05

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp bertol

2001/06

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp bertol

2001/07

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp bertol

2001/08

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp bertol

2001/09

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp bertol

2001/10

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp dww

2001/11

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp dww

2001/12

5

bubulle lee hwansing fjp dww

2002/01

5

bubulle hwansing fjp lee dww

2002/02

5

bubulle hwansing fjp lee dww

2002/03

5

bubulle hwansing fjp lee sc

2002/04

5

bubulle hwansing fjp lee sc

2002/05

5

bubulle hwansing fjp lee sc

2002/06

5

bubulle hwansing fjp lee sc

2002/07

5

bubulle hwansing fjp lee dww

2002/08

5

bubulle hwansing fjp cate lee

2002/09

5

bubulle hwansing fjp cate lee

2002/10

5

bubulle hwansing fjp cate lee

2002/11

5

bubulle hwansing fjp cate lee

2002/12

5

bubulle hwansing fjp cate lee

2003/01

7

sanxiyn bubulle fjp dww hwansing cate lee

2003/02

6

bubulle fjp dww hwansing cate lee

2003/03

6

bubulle fjp dww hwansing cate lee

2003/04

6

bubulle fjp hwansing dww cate lee

2003/05

6

bubulle fjp hwansing dww cate lee

2003/06

6

bubulle fjp hwansing dww cate lee

2003/07

6

bubulle fjp hwansing dww cate lee

2003/08

6

bubulle fjp hwansing dww cate lee

2003/09

6

bubulle fjp hwansing dww cate lee

2003/10

6

bubulle fjp hwansing dww cate lee

2003/11

6

bubulle hwansing fjp dww cate lee

2003/12

6

bubulle fjp hwansing dww cate lee

2004/01

6

hwansing bubulle dww cate lee:34 fjp

2004/02

6

hwansing bubulle dww cate lee:41 fjp

2004/03

5

bubulle hwansing cate lee:90 fjp

2004/04

6

bubulle hwansing cate lee:197 fjp elmig

2004/05

6

bubulle hwansing lee:372 fjp dww elmig

2004/06

5

bubulle hwansing lee:60 fjp dww

2004/07

6

cjwatson bubulle hwansing dww lee:59 fjp

2004/08

6

bubulle hwansing dww cate lee fjp

2004/09

6

bubulle hwansing dww cate lee fjp

2004/10

6

hwansing bubulle dww cate lee fjp

2004/11

5

hwansing bubulle lee fjp sc

2004/12

5

bubulle hwansing lee fp fjp

2005/01

5

bubulle hwansing dww fjp lee:34

2005/02

5

bubulle hwansing dww fjp lee:39

2005/03

5

bubulle hwansing dww fjp lee:59

2005/04

6

bubulle hwansing dww cate fjp lee:41

2005/05

6

bubulle hwansing dww cate fjp lee:102

2005/06

5

hwansing bubulle dww fjp lee:114

2005/07

5

hwansing bubulle dww fjp lee:38

2005/08

6

hwansing bubulle dww fjp lee:8 fp

2005/09

6

hwansing bubulle dww fjp fp lee:2

2005/10

6

hwansing bubulle dww fjp fp lee:25

2005/11

6

hwansing bubulle dww fjp cate lee:14

2005/12

6

hwansing dww bubulle fjp cate lee:119

2006/01

6

philbat dww fjp sc hwansing lee:28

2006/02

6

philbat dww fjp sc hwansing lee:14

2006/03

6

philbat dww fjp hwansing sc lee:26

2006/04

6

dww philbat fjp hwansing bubulle lee:36

2006/05

6

dww philbat fjp hwansing bubulle lee

2006/06

6

dww philbat fjp hwansing bubulle lee:11

2006/07

6

philbat fjp hwansing dww bubulle lee:9

2006/08

5

philbat fjp hwansing dww bubulle

2006/09

5

philbat fjp hwansing dww bubulle

2006/10

5

dww philbat fp fjp hwansing

2006/11

5

dww philbat fp fjp hwansing

2006/12

5

dww philbat fp fjp bubulle

2007/01

5

fjp dww fp hwansing bubulle

2007/02

5

fjp dww fp hwansing bubulle

2007/03

5

fjp dww fp hwansing bubulle

2007/04

6

fjp fp philbat hwansing bubulle dww

2007/05

6

fjp fp philbat hwansing bubulle dww

2007/06

5

fjp fp hwansing bubulle dww

2007/07

5

fjp fp hwansing bubulle dww

2007/08

7

fjp fp hwansing bubulle sc dww lee:4

2007/09

7

fjp fp hwansing bubulle sc dww lee:1

2007/10

7

hwansing fjp fp bubulle sc dww lee:7

2007/11

7

hwansing fjp fp bubulle sc dww lee:1

2007/12

7

hwansing bubulle fjp fp sc dww lee:2

2008/01

6

fjp fp philbat waldi dww lee:6

2008/02

6

fjp fp philbat dww bubulle lee:3

2008/03

6

fjp fp philbat waldi dww lee:4

2008/04

6

fjp fp philbat waldi dww lee:2

2008/05

6

fjp fp dww bubulle hwansing lee:2

2008/06

6

fjp bubulle fp dww hwansing lee:1

2008/07

6

fjp bubulle fp dww hwansing lee:2

2008/08

6

fjp bubulle fp hwansing dww lee:2

2008/09

6

fjp bubulle fp hwansing dww lee:2

2008/10

6

fjp bubulle fp hwansing dww lee:10

2008/11

6

fjp bubulle fp hwansing dww lee:1

2008/12

6

bubulle fp fjp hwansing dww lee:0

2009/01

6

fjp fp bubulle hwansing dww lee

2009/02

7

fjp fp philbat bubulle hwansing dww lee:1

2009/03

7

fjp fp philbat elmig bubulle hwansing lee:0

2009/04

7

fp fjp philbat elmig bubulle hwansing lee:2

2009/05

6

dww fjp hwansing fp bubulle lee

2009/06

6

dww hwansing bubulle fp fjp lee

2009/07

6

fjp dww bubulle cate fp lee

2009/08

6

fjp bubulle cate dww fp lee

2009/09

6

fjp bubulle cate dww lee fp

2009/10

6

bubulle dww fjp lee hwansing sc

2009/11

5

fjp bubulle fp lee:3 sc

2009/12

5

fjp bubulle fp lee:16 sc