Differences between revisions 1 and 81 (spanning 80 versions)
Revision 1 as of 2006-08-11 00:27:22
Size: 3874
Editor: ?FransPop
Comment: Initial version
Revision 81 as of 2007-01-24 06:35:15
Size: 6712
Editor: ?FransPop
Comment: One more post-Etch goal
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 1: Line 1:
This is a tracking page for issues that need to be dealt with before we can release RC1 of DebianInstaller for Etch.

Note that we may work around some of these issues by not including certain problematic architectures in the beta release.
## page was renamed from DebianInstaller/EtchRC1Prep
This is a tracking page for issues that need to be dealt with before we can release RC2 of DebianInstaller for Etch.
Line 13: Line 12:
 * Switch to 2.6.17
 * Removal of 2.4 kernel support
   * 2.6 floppies for i386, sparc
   * code cleanup
   * remove devfs support (could be risky; see also Colin's [https://wiki.ubuntu.com/NoMoreDevfs devfs migration plan])
 * Library upgrade for graphical installer
 * Kernel 2.6.18 - waiting for next kernel upload
Line 21: Line 15:
 * Supplemental repository support for udebs
   * Started by Bastian Blank, probably won't happen for beta3
 * Persistent device naming
 * partman
   * Merge ext3 support into partman-basicfilesystems so it is available by default in lowmem installations
   * Change ext3 mkfs to include the resize_inode option at least with LVM
   * Note: changes below may need partman-auto user interface change; see [http://lists.debian.org/debian-boot/2006/06/msg01187.html this mail] and follow ups
   * partman-auto-crypto
   * Get Simon Huggins to fold in the working partman-auto-raid stuff (+ partman-auto/grub-installer) changes for preseeded automated RAID installs.
 * g-i
   * library upgrade
   * automatic font switching on language selection
 * Graphical installer
Line 34: Line 17:
   * check what is really supported and what not (mainly powerpc)
 * Philip Hand's preseeding changes
 * Update/replacement of/for localization-config
 * Implement/improve/test IPv6 support
 * SELinux support
   * still some keymap issues
 * Check d-i memory usage (all arches!) and update lowmem limits
   * done for i386
 * Test free memory check in partman-(auto-)crypto - '''works'''[[BR]]Should be implemented for partman-lvm, and possibly partman-md, as well
Line 40: Line 22:
   * [http://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/2006/07/msg00744.html Stop creating /etc/environment] ([http://bugs.debian.org/379052 #379052])
   * Change "link in /" to "link in /boot"?
   * Switch from dhcp to dhcp3 in d-i and for installed system
   * Get currently untranslated messages during pkgsel translated
   * Add option to load additional CDs during pkgsel (needs support in cdebconf for switching CDs during tasksel)?
   * Recognize netinst/full CD installs so we can lower priority on the "use mirror" question in apt-setup; note: this may make installing KDE task from full CD practically impossible
   * Add ppc64 support
   * Switch from dhcp to dhcp3 in d-i and for installed system[[BR]]Note: done for installed system; post-Etch for d-i
   * Recognize netinst/full CD installs so we can lower priority on the "use mirror" question in apt-setup -- [http://lists.debian.org/debian-boot/2006/11/msg00583.html discussion]
Line 51: Line 28:
 * Well, give us a day or two...

=== Other changes ===

 * Option to install extra individual packages in pkgsel (boot prompt or preseeding)
 * More new arm subarches
 * Both newt and gtk frontends have "dark" theme for visually handicapped
 * Graphical installer
   * some keyboard/keymap issues solved
   * touchpads now work (though not yet optimal)
   * automatic switching of default font on language selection
   * console switching problem on AMD64 solved
 * Language support
   * Added: Belarusian, Georgian, Malayalam, Kurdish
   * No longer supported: ...
 * Various
   * Support for ftp protocol re-enabled (though without selection from country/mirror lists)
   * Option to blacklist modules
   * ...
Line 61: Line 45:
   * none yet    * Issues bringing up network devices on booting the installed system
     * Joey proposed a workaround in the network configuration ([http://bugs.debian.org/403706 #403706]). Question is if this is still needed as reported issues look to be solved in udev (0.103-2).
Line 63: Line 48:
   * libparted does not support ext3 partitions that have dir_index or resize_inode set (complains about "incompatible feature enabled"); this means that in partman resizing such partitions or copying data to (from?) them ([http://bugs.debian.org/405098 #405098]) is not supported; also reported in [https://launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/parted/+bug/59620 ubuntu]
   * CD-ROM support on sparc32 (esp) broken in kernel; see e.g. #393786
Line 64: Line 51:
   * "device switching" after reboot on systems with multiple NICs or HD controllers; is really an old issue but occurs more frequently after switch to udev      * Patch committed for partman-partitioning that disables partitioning for Vista partitions
     * Issue in ntfsresize has been resolved
     * Issue in libparted is slowly being worked on
   * "Device switching" after reboot on systems with multiple HD controllers; is really an old issue but occurs more frequently after switch to udev
   * Graphical installer
     * Usability: <enter> does not activate <Continue> button for some template types
     * Not possible to generate random keys (often used for swap) for crypto setup due to missing entropy plugin
Line 67: Line 60:
     * some subarches currently disabled
     * Airport Extreme broken in 2.6.16 ([http://bugs.debian.org/358833 #358833]; reported by Eugen Dedu)
     * snd-powermac no longer loaded by default as it will lock up some systems; add to /etc/modules manually
     * Software raid not supported on systems using mac partition tables ([http://bugs.debian.org/397973 #397973])
   * Some very recent CD/DVD devices seem not supported ([http://bugs.debian.org/407759 #407759])
   * On mips a disk device may be detected as a partition ([http://bugs.debian.org/404950 #404950]). This is really a kernel problem in the driver, but could easily be worked around in partman-base (definitions.sh).
   * Should we do something in D-I about the TCP window scaling issue ([http://bugs.debian.org/401435 #401435])? Probably not, but get it mentioned in the Release Notes.
Line 71: Line 65:
   * Some display problems using UTF-8 locales [http://bugs.debian.org/348032 #348032] and ["UTF8BrokenApps"]    * Some display problems using UTF-8 locales ([http://bugs.debian.org/348032 #348032] and ["UTF8BrokenApps"])
Line 75: Line 69:
 * Check d-i memory usage (all arches!)  * Wanted packages
   * '''fontconfig''' (2.4.2-1)
   * module-init-tools (3.3-pre4-1)
   * ...
Line 77: Line 74:
 * udeb removals (temporary, unofficial g-i udebs)
 * Request removals for remaining 2.2/2.4 kernels and kernel udebs
 * Check what happened to development packages due to [http://bugs.debian.org/301138 #301138] possibly getting solved
Line 80: Line 76:
   * No longer include 2.4 stuff
   * Update tasks and popcon
 * Finish last bits of udeb transition (not required)
Line 84: Line 77:
= Post-RC1 development = = Post-RC2 development =
Line 86: Line 79:
Hopefully not much... Hopefully there won't be an RC3.

= Post-Etch ("Lenny") development =

 * Support to load and install from more than one full CD or DVD
 * Support for installing Debian on hardware requiring drivers/firmware not in the regular kernel images
   * includes supplemental repository support for udebs Started by Bastian Blank, probably won't happen for beta3; work parked in {{{people/waldi}}}
 * Implement/improve/test IPv6 support
   * proposed patch for IPv6 support in busybox wget: [http://bugs.debian.org/395839 #395839]
 * Find replacement for the ISC DHCP client in d-i
   * dhcp3 is really too big for d-i
   * busybox has something but that will probably need to be extended to avoid regressions
   * klibc has also a DHCP client, it even can identify itself with vendor id "d-i"[[BR]]FJP: but do we want to use klibc in images when we already have libc?
 * General cleanup
   * removal of 2.4 kernel support
   * general code cleanup, e.g. old backwards compatibility hacks
 * Persistent device naming for disks
 * partman
   * merge ext3 support into partman-basicfilesystems so it is available by default in lowmem installations
   * try to get some issues in libparted fixed: [http://bugs.debian.org/406680 #406680], [http://bugs.debian.org/328629 #328629], [http://bugs.debian.org/377263 #377263]
 * Split the initrd into three
   * the 1st containing the basic system
   * the 2nd containing drivers for the latest hardware (so only this "initrd" needs modification for new hardware)[[BR]]FJP: is this even realistic?
   * the 3rd being language support, which only gets loaded if enough memory is available - [http://wiki.debian.org/I18n/Extremadura2006ModularizingD-I more detailed plans for this]
 * Build system
   * Add a new build target or method to build all packages from the SVN and build an image with them rather than build with uploaded packages. This would speed up interactive reviews of translations as well as other coordinated changes. Of course, it would break often..:-)
 * Extensions
   * Integration of http frontend developed by Attilio?
   * Support for installing a server with Xen instances as suggested by Russel Coker at [http://etbe.blogspot.com/2007/01/lca-talk.html LCA]?
 * Various
   * Finish last bits of udeb transition
   * Change "link in /" to "link in /boot"?
   * Switch from {{{console-data}}} to {{{console-common}}}

This is a tracking page for issues that need to be dealt with before we can release RC2 of DebianInstaller for Etch.

  • For day-to-day issues, see ["DebianInstaller/Today"].

Release goals overview

To Do

Main Goals

  • Kernel 2.6.18 - waiting for next kernel upload

Other Goals

  • Graphical installer
    • cleaning up and debugging
    • still some keymap issues
  • Check d-i memory usage (all arches!) and update lowmem limits
    • done for i386
  • Test free memory check in partman-(auto-)crypto - works?BRShould be implemented for partman-lvm, and possibly partman-md, as well

  • Various
    • Switch from dhcp to dhcp3 in d-i and for installed system?BRNote: done for installed system; post-Etch for d-i

    • Recognize netinst/full CD installs so we can lower priority on the "use mirror" question in apt-setup -- [http://lists.debian.org/debian-boot/2006/11/msg00583.html discussion]

    • Make "expert" install default to "priority=medium"?

Done

  • Both newt and gtk frontends have "dark" theme for visually handicapped
  • Graphical installer
    • some keyboard/keymap issues solved
    • touchpads now work (though not yet optimal)
    • automatic switching of default font on language selection
    • console switching problem on AMD64 solved
  • Language support
    • Added: Belarusian, Georgian, Malayalam, Kurdish
    • No longer supported: ...
  • Various
    • Support for ftp protocol re-enabled (though without selection from country/mirror lists)
    • Option to blacklist modules
    • ...

Issues

  • Blocking
    • Issues bringing up network devices on booting the installed system
      • Joey proposed a workaround in the network configuration ([http://bugs.debian.org/403706 #403706]). Question is if this is still needed as reported issues look to be solved in udev (0.103-2).

  • Maybe blocking
    • libparted does not support ext3 partitions that have dir_index or resize_inode set (complains about "incompatible feature enabled"); this means that in partman resizing such partitions or copying data to (from?) them ([http://bugs.debian.org/405098 #405098]) is not supported; also reported in [https://launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/parted/+bug/59620 ubuntu]

    • CD-ROM support on sparc32 (esp) broken in kernel; see e.g. #393786
    • NTFS resize corruption for Vista partitions (NTFS 3.1) ([http://bugs.debian.org/379835 #379835])

      • Patch committed for partman-partitioning that disables partitioning for Vista partitions
      • Issue in ntfsresize has been resolved
      • Issue in libparted is slowly being worked on
    • "Device switching" after reboot on systems with multiple HD controllers; is really an old issue but occurs more frequently after switch to udev
    • Graphical installer
      • Usability: <enter> does not activate <Continue> button for some template types

      • Not possible to generate random keys (often used for swap) for crypto setup due to missing entropy plugin
    • Some issues for ppc:
      • floppy installations broken because device node for swim3 module is not generated by udev (probably kernel issue)
      • Software raid not supported on systems using mac partition tables ([http://bugs.debian.org/397973 #397973])

    • Some very recent CD/DVD devices seem not supported ([http://bugs.debian.org/407759 #407759])

    • On mips a disk device may be detected as a partition ([http://bugs.debian.org/404950 #404950]). This is really a kernel problem in the driver, but could easily be worked around in partman-base (definitions.sh).

    • Should we do something in D-I about the TCP window scaling issue ([http://bugs.debian.org/401435 #401435])? Probably not, but get it mentioned in the Release Notes.

  • Non-blocking

To Do before release

  • Wanted packages
    • fontconfig (2.4.2-1)

    • module-init-tools (3.3-pre4-1)
    • ...
  • Check status/issues/migration for non-d-i udebs
  • Check what happened to development packages due to [http://bugs.debian.org/301138 #301138] possibly getting solved

  • Update debian-cd

Post-RC2 development

Hopefully there won't be an RC3.

Post-Etch ("Lenny") development

  • Support to load and install from more than one full CD or DVD
  • Support for installing Debian on hardware requiring drivers/firmware not in the regular kernel images
    • includes supplemental repository support for udebs Started by Bastian Blank, probably won't happen for beta3; work parked in people/waldi

  • Implement/improve/test IPv6 support
  • Find replacement for the ISC DHCP client in d-i
    • dhcp3 is really too big for d-i
    • busybox has something but that will probably need to be extended to avoid regressions
    • klibc has also a DHCP client, it even can identify itself with vendor id "d-i"?BRFJP: but do we want to use klibc in images when we already have libc?

  • General cleanup
    • removal of 2.4 kernel support
    • general code cleanup, e.g. old backwards compatibility hacks
  • Persistent device naming for disks
  • partman
  • Split the initrd into three
    • the 1st containing the basic system
    • the 2nd containing drivers for the latest hardware (so only this "initrd" needs modification for new hardware)?BRFJP: is this even realistic?

    • the 3rd being language support, which only gets loaded if enough memory is available - [http://wiki.debian.org/I18n/Extremadura2006ModularizingD-I more detailed plans for this]

  • Build system
    • Add a new build target or method to build all packages from the SVN and build an image with them rather than build with uploaded packages. This would speed up interactive reviews of translations as well as other coordinated changes. Of course, it would break often..:-)
  • Extensions
  • Various
    • Finish last bits of udeb transition
    • Change "link in /" to "link in /boot"?
    • Switch from console-data to console-common